Review | Songlines

Dare

Rating: ★★

View album and artist details

Album and Artist Details

Artist/band:

Banter

Label:

Mrs Casey Records

July/2019

Featuring Simon Care on melodeon and concertina, with Nina Zella on keyboards and vocals, and brass and percussion from Tim Walker, this well-connected trio still style themselves as ‘the world's smallest big band,’ and, as on their bracing debut Yes, they can make a pretty big noise if it suits them. They've been gigging for the past 18 months since that striking introduction, and when they lay into the traditional dance tunes here, as they often do, their sheer gusto is impressively infectious and enjoyable.

On the other hand, the several self-penned tracks tend towards the disappointingly underwhelming, straining for lyrical relevance but mostly just sounding hackneyed, despite their obvious instrumental skills and a continuing cheery disregard for musical boundaries. Unfortunately, any pleasure to be had from its diversity quickly goes astray in the face of the collection's irritating ups and downs. Matters could well be very different in the live arena, of course. Quite what a virtually unreconstructed take on The Police's always dubious ‘Roxanne’ is doing here, let alone closing the album on a faintly desperate note, is anybody's guess.

Subscribe from only £7.50

Start your journey and discover the very best music from around the world.

Subscribe

View the Current
Issue

Take a peek inside the latest issue of Songlines magazine.

Find out more